Okay, this could get pretty confusing, so I'll tell you what is going to happen:
If I'm correct, the current plan between me and HSRT is that we will write two stories - SIMULTANEOUSLY - and write short stories!
EDIT by HSRT: And since it was really confusing for me...
1-1 = Plot 1, Chapter 1
2-1 = Plot 2, Chapter 1
And so on and so forth! ... it's plot first, not chapter, like I thought first!
... hope you don't mind my edit, budd-eh'!
I'll keep the second story's plot a secret for now... 
And while I'm doing that... may as well cross that out. ... man, I'm getting antsy. Nothing to moderate lately, besides unstickying and stickying.

CHAPTER 1-1 (Ah, Super Paper Mario...): The Portal
What would you do if your computer was a portal? If it could bring you anywhere you wanted, let you do anything imaginable?
What would you do...
...If it was a one-way trip into the internet?
One kid thought over that question on the bus ride home. Finally, he could get back home and log on to BHZ!
When he got to the site, something odd happened. A small, purple dot formed in the center of his screen. It quickly grew, until a spiraling vortex covered the screen.
It looked almost three-dimensional. The boy reached out to feel it, and found himself sucked in.
He soon woke up in pitch black. All he could see was a bookstand and the Thnikkaman walking back and forth.
And then there was a green goblin. The boy got up, and walked around, nearly avoiding a bottomless pit...with school spirit. Suddenly, he ran into the bookstand, and passed out.
Hours later, he woke up and found himself on what seemed like a barren, moonlike landscape. As he walked around, he noticed a guarded building. One of the guards noticed him approaching, and stopped him.
"Halt! Name please!"
The boy told his name, but was not allowed entry. Suddenly, he got an idea.
"On BHZ, I'm called Rather On Fire."
The guard replied, "Oh, Rather! Come in!"
Rather On Fire was allowed entry. In the building, all he saw was a small elevator. He went down to the lower floor, and found a large, glowing sphere. An older man was also there.
"Hey, it's Rather!" Said the man.
"Where are we?"
"This is the power core for Burning Horizon's Homestar Runner Fan Planet."
"P...planet? I thought it was forum!"
"Well...it was. You can call this the forum's second upgrade. BHZ hasn't told just how he made it yet, so we know as much as you."
"So, how'd you get here?"
"BHZ brought us here. How'd
you get here?"
"I just went to the site, and my computer became a portal."
"That's not supposed to happen...Only admins and mods are supposed to be here for the moment."
"Mods? Is HSRT here, too?"
"Yeah, but we're not sure where he went. Hey, while you're here, can you help us find him?"
"Sure! Say, who are you, anyways?"
"My name...is Potthole!"
TO BE CONTINUED...